Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Comparing methods for research mentorship: structuring graduate student feedback using the Socratic method versus the Critical Response Process (CRP)

  • Alissa Ruth
  • , Melissa Beresford
  • , Amber Wutich
  • , H. Russell Bernard
  • , Cindi SturtzSreetharan
  • , Liam Gleason
  • , Margaret V. du Bray
  • , Blanca Yagüe
  • , Anaís Delilah Roque
  • , Sarah Renkert
  • , Robin G. Nelson
  • , Rosalyn Negrón
  • , Mehrnaz Moghaddam
  • , Katherine Mayfour
  • , Oswaldo Medina-Ramírez
  • , Krista Harper
  • , Patricio Cruz y
  • Arizona State University
  • San Jose State University
  • University Northern Colorado
  • University of Utah
  • Duke University
  • Purdue University
  • City University of New York
  • University of Massachusetts
  • University of California at Davis

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

Abstract

Recent research finds that a classic approach to research mentorship–the Socratic method–where faculty foster learning by posing probing questions, can also create gender and racial disparities in learning gains. A newer research mentorship method, the Critical Response Process (CRP), may address these shortcomings by giving students control over the flow and quality of feedback they receive. We test and compare the efficacy of these two methods in a three-week, summer-intensive graduate program. We assess student (n = 20) and faculty (n = 4) perceptions of each method’s strengths and weaknesses using participant-observation, surveys, and focus groups. While there are strengths in both methods, some students preferred the familiarity of the Socratic method, while others felt it created anxiety. Most students felt empowered by the CRP, as it provided more control over the feedback process. We conclude by providing recommendations for advancing research feedback methods to better align with inclusive and student-centered pedagogies.

Original languageEnglish
JournalTeaching in Higher Education
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - 2025

ASJC Scopus Subject Areas

  • Education

Keywords

  • Critical Response Process
  • Graduate students
  • mentorship
  • research proposal development
  • Socratic method

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Comparing methods for research mentorship: structuring graduate student feedback using the Socratic method versus the Critical Response Process (CRP)'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this